Skip to content
Trusted by 10,000+ travelers • Updated weekly with new provider ratings
JetSet Protect
Real Scenario

Hurricane Season Travel Insurance Strategies for Caribbean & Coastal Trips

Navigate hurricane season with the right insurance coverage, including when to buy, what's covered, and how Cancel For Any Reason works during tropical storms.

1/15/20259 min readScenario

Hurricane season timing

Atlantic Hurricane Season: June 1 – November 30 Peak activity: August through October Pacific Hurricane Season: May 15 – November 30

Popular destinations affected: Caribbean islands, Mexico (both coasts), Florida, Gulf Coast, Hawaii, Central America.

The insurance timing problem

The catch-22: Once a hurricane is named and tracking toward your destination, it's too late to buy coverage for that specific storm.

Example:

  • Monday: Hurricane Maria forms and is named
  • Tuesday: You buy travel insurance for your Puerto Rico trip next week
  • Wednesday: Maria hits Puerto Rico
  • Thursday: You try to cancel trip and file claim
  • Result: ❌ Denied - storm was known when you purchased insurance

When to buy insurance

✅ Buy BEFORE hurricane season starts (May for Pacific, early June for Atlantic) ✅ Buy within 14-21 days of first trip payment (for pre-existing condition waiver AND best hurricane coverage) ✅ Buy before any storms form that could affect your region

❌ Don't wait until:

  • A storm is named
  • A storm is tracking toward your destination
  • Weather forecasts show tropical development
  • You see hurricane on the news

What's covered vs what's not

✅ Covered scenarios

1. Mandatory evacuation before you depart

  • Government issues evacuation order for your hotel/destination area
  • You cancel trip before departure
  • Coverage: Trip cancellation (100% of prepaid costs)

Example: Booked Key West hotel. Category 4 hurricane mandatory evacuation issued 3 days before arrival. Outcome: Full refund of non-refundable hotel, flights, tours

2. Hurricane hits before you depart, making destination uninhabitable

  • Your hotel is destroyed or deemed unsafe
  • Destination has no power/water/services
  • Airport is closed

Coverage: Trip cancellation

Example: Hurricane Irma destroyed hotel in St. Maarten. Trip was 10 days after hurricane. Outcome: Full trip cancellation refund (hotel confirmed property was uninhabitable)

3. You're already there and must evacuate early

  • Mandatory evacuation while you're on vacation
  • You cut trip short to leave before hurricane hits

Coverage: Trip interruption (unused portion + extra costs to get home)

Example: On day 5 of 10-day Cancun vacation, mandatory evacuation issued. Covered: 5 unused hotel nights + change flight fees to get home early

4. Hurricane delays your departure home

  • Airport closes due to hurricane
  • Your return flight is canceled
  • You need extra hotel nights

Coverage: Travel delay benefits (typically $100-200/day after 6-12 hour delay)

Example: Hurricane closes Miami airport. Stuck in Bahamas 3 extra days. Covered: Hotel ($150/night × 3 nights), meals, necessities

❌ NOT covered (without CFAR)

1. Fear of travel / hurricane might hit

  • Hurricane is forecasted but hasn't hit yet
  • You're scared to travel
  • Weather channel says there's a risk

Example: Hurricane predicted to be Category 3. You're afraid. Hotel still open, no evacuation order. Outcome: Not covered (no mandatory evacuation, hotel operational)

2. Hurricane hits a week before, destination is recovering

  • Hurricane passed days before your trip
  • Destination is open but damaged
  • You don't want to go to a disaster zone

Example: Hurricane hit Jamaica 5 days before your arrival. Airport open, hotel open (but damaged pool, no beach chairs). Outcome: Not covered (destination is operational, just not ideal)

3. Cruise itinerary changes

  • Cruise reroutes to avoid hurricane
  • You still have a cruise, just different ports

Example: Cruise skips Bahamas (hurricane) and goes to Mexico instead. Outcome: Not covered (you still have a cruise, just different route)

4. General hurricane season anxiety

  • "It's hurricane season, I don't feel safe"
  • No specific storm threat

Example: Booked Caribbean in September. Worried about hurricanes in general. Outcome: Not covered (need specific event, not general anxiety)

Cancel For Any Reason (CFAR): The hurricane season game-changer

What CFAR does

Cancel For Any Reason coverage lets you cancel for literally any reason and get 50-75% of your prepaid trip costs back.

This includes:

  • "I'm scared of the hurricane season"
  • "Weather forecast looks bad"
  • "I changed my mind"
  • "I just don't want to go anymore"

CFAR requirements

  1. Must purchase within 14-21 days of first trip payment (strict deadline!)
  2. Must insure 100% of trip cost
  3. Must cancel at least 48 hours before scheduled departure
  4. Reimburses 50-75% of trip cost (not 100%)

CFAR cost

Adds 40-50% to your premium

Example:

  • $5,000 Caribbean trip
  • Standard travel insurance: $300
  • With CFAR add-on: $420-$450 (extra $120-$150)

When CFAR makes sense for hurricane season

✅ Buy CFAR if:

  • Traveling August-October (peak hurricane season)
  • Destination has history of hurricanes (Florida, Caribbean, Gulf Coast)
  • Trip is expensive ($5,000+) and non-refundable
  • You want flexibility to cancel for any weather concern

❌ Skip CFAR if:

  • Traveling outside hurricane season
  • Trip is refundable/flexible
  • Destination is less hurricane-prone
  • Budget-conscious (CFAR adds significant cost)

Hurricane season strategies by scenario

Scenario 1: June/July travel (early hurricane season)

Risk level: Low-medium (storms less frequent)

Strategy:

  • Buy standard travel insurance within 14 days of booking
  • CFAR optional (lower risk period)
  • Monitor weather 2 weeks before departure

Recommended coverage:

  • Trip cancellation: 100%
  • Trip interruption: 150%
  • Travel delay: $1,200+

Scenario 2: August-October travel (peak hurricane season)

Risk level: High

Strategy:

  • Buy travel insurance IMMEDIATELY when booking
  • Add CFAR for maximum flexibility
  • Buy insurance before any storms form
  • Consider refundable/flexible bookings

Recommended coverage:

  • Trip cancellation with CFAR: 75% reimbursement
  • Trip interruption: 150%
  • Travel delay: $1,500+
  • Hurricane/weather coverage included

Scenario 3: Cruise during hurricane season

Risk level: Medium-high (cruises can reroute, but may cancel)

Strategy:

  • Buy cruise-specific insurance (not cruise line's insurance)
  • Add CFAR if cruise cost is $3,000+ per person
  • Buy within 14 days for pre-existing condition waiver

Recommended coverage:

  • Trip cancellation: 100% (cruise lines have strict refund policies)
  • CFAR: Yes (cruise rerouting doesn't trigger standard cancellation)
  • Missed port coverage: Included in better policies
  • Medical evacuation: $500k (ship evacuations are expensive)

Scenario 4: Destination wedding in Caribbean (September)

Risk level: High + high stakes

Strategy:

  • Must buy CFAR (standard coverage won't cover "wedding canceled due to weather concerns")
  • Buy insurance within 14 days of first deposit (venue, travel, etc.)
  • Consider postponement insurance separately (covers wedding-specific costs)

Special considerations:

  • Standard travel insurance covers YOU canceling due to mandatory evacuation
  • Does NOT cover bride/groom canceling wedding due to hurricane fears
  • CFAR is essential for flexibility

Scenario 5: All-inclusive resort (Mexico, Jamaica, Dominican Republic)

Risk level: Medium

Strategy:

  • Buy travel insurance within 14 days
  • CFAR recommended for peace of mind
  • Check resort's hurricane policy (some offer reschedule credits)

Tip: Many all-inclusive resorts offer "hurricane guarantees" (free reschedule if hurricane hits). Combine with CFAR for maximum protection.

Real hurricane scenarios

✅ COVERED: Hurricane Irma (2017)

Scenario: Family booked St. Maarten vacation, leaving September 10. Hurricane Irma hit September 6, destroying resort.

Insurance: Travel Guard Preferred (purchased in May) Trip cost: $8,500

Outcome:

  • Hotel confirmed destroyed (force majeure cancellation)
  • Airline waived change fees (but flights were non-refundable)
  • Insurance paid: $8,500 full trip cancellation
  • Approved ✅

Lesson: Buying early (before storm formed) = full coverage

❌ DENIED: Hurricane Maria (2017)

Scenario: Couple booked Puerto Rico honeymoon. Hurricane Maria was named Sept 16. They bought insurance Sept 17 for Sept 25 trip. Maria hit PR on Sept 20.

Insurance: Allianz OneTrip (purchased AFTER storm was named) Trip cost: $6,000

Outcome:

  • Hurricane was "known event" when insurance purchased
  • Exclusion: "We don't cover known hurricanes/storms"
  • Insurance paid: $0
  • Denied ❌

Lesson: Buying AFTER storm is named = no coverage for that storm

✅ COVERED: CFAR for hurricane anxiety (2023)

Scenario: Solo traveler booked Turks & Caicos for September. No specific hurricane, but forecast showed active season. Got nervous and canceled 10 days before trip.

Insurance: Travelex with CFAR (purchased in June, 3 days after booking) Trip cost: $4,200

Outcome:

  • No mandatory evacuation (wouldn't be covered under standard)
  • CFAR covered "any reason" cancellation
  • Insurance paid: $3,150 (75% of trip cost)
  • Approved ✅

Lesson: CFAR covers fear/change of mind, standard policies don't

❌ DENIED: Cruise itinerary change

Scenario: Cruise rerouted from Bahamas to Mexico to avoid Hurricane Dorian. Passenger wanted refund because "Bahamas was the whole reason I booked."

Insurance: Travel Guard (no CFAR) Trip cost: $3,500

Outcome:

  • Cruise still operated (just different route)
  • No mandatory evacuation or trip cancellation
  • "Itinerary change" not covered under standard policy
  • Insurance paid: $0
  • Denied ❌

Lesson: Cruise rerouting ≠ trip cancellation. Need CFAR to cancel for this reason.

Coverage checklist for hurricane season

Before booking a trip during hurricane season, ensure your travel insurance includes:

  • [ ] Trip cancellation: 100% coverage for mandatory evacuation
  • [ ] Trip interruption: 150% coverage (in case you're evacuated mid-trip)
  • [ ] Travel delay: At least $1,200 (hurricanes cause multi-day delays)
  • [ ] Hurricane/weather coverage: Explicitly included (check policy)
  • [ ] Cancel For Any Reason: 75% reimbursement (if you want flexibility)
  • [ ] Named storm exclusion check: Verify policy doesn't exclude known storms IF you buy before they're named
  • [ ] Purchase timing: Within 14-21 days of first trip payment

Best providers for hurricane season coverage

Best for CFAR:

  1. Travel Guard Preferred: 75% CFAR reimbursement
  2. Travelex Travel Select: 75% CFAR, good value
  3. Allianz AllTrips Premier: 50% CFAR (lower than competitors)

Best for cruises:

  1. Travel Guard: Supplier default, high trip cancellation limits
  2. Allianz: Cruise-specific plans available

Best overall value:

  1. Travelex: Lowest cost with CFAR option
  2. Seven Corners: Budget-friendly with solid weather coverage

Frequently asked questions

Q: Can I buy insurance after a hurricane is named if it's not heading toward my destination? A: Depends on the policy. Some insurers exclude coverage for any named storm in the Atlantic basin once it forms. Others only exclude if it's tracking toward your specific destination. Read the fine print.

Q: What if the hurricane changes path after I buy insurance? A: You're covered! If you bought before it was named, you're covered even if it later tracks to your destination.

Q: Do I get a refund if hurricane season is unusually quiet? A: No. Insurance premiums are non-refundable, even if you don't use the policy.

Q: Will my hotel refund me if there's a hurricane? A: Maybe. Many resorts have hurricane policies (free reschedule, credits). Check before booking. Travel insurance covers what the hotel WON'T refund.

Q: Can I buy insurance the day before my trip if no hurricanes are active? A: Yes, but you'll lose pre-existing condition waivers and CFAR eligibility (must buy within 14-21 days of first trip payment).

Q: What counts as "mandatory evacuation"? A: Government-issued evacuation order for your specific area. Voluntary evacuations usually don't count.

Next steps

Hurricane season doesn't have to mean canceled vacations—just smart planning and the right insurance coverage.